The legalization of physician-assisted suicide is being considered in a handful of states as advocates with disabilities on both sides of the issue fight to be heard. Oregon and Washington have already approved right-to-die laws, and Montana’s Supreme Court made it legal in 2009. Voters in Massachusetts narrowly defeated an assisted suicide ballot measure last November. During the latest legislative cycle, Connecticut and Kansas failed to get bills out of committee. In February, New Jersey’s Death with Dignity Act passed out of committee on a 7 to 2 vote. Hawaii has a bill pending, and in the latest victory for proponents of assisted suicide, the Vermont House, on April 30, gave preliminary approval by a vote of 80-57 to a bill that had gone down to defeat six years earlier.
Connecticut resident Cathy Ludlum, 50, who has spinal muscular atrophy, opposes physician-assisted suicide. She says people with disabilities are already at risk. “I have had to fight with medical practitioners who were well-meaning but did not feel like I had a life that was as good as or as worth saving as theirs,” she says.
Ludlum says pain control is vital, and those who are in unbearable pain can use terminal sedation, where a person is kept in an unconscious state until death occurs. She believes doctors aren’t trained to understand the difference between life with a disability and the idea of suffering. She says doctors work hard to alleviate suffering but often overlook other options unique to each situation. She encourages people to talk with their doctor about end-of-life concerns.
In Oregon and Washington, those seeking assistance in dying must have a terminal diagnosis — le