New Mobility Logo

Login Username
Login Password

Hot Topics

This Month's Cover Image
Subscribe Now! Renew Subscription Make Payment Online Version Read This Issue Customer Service Search Site

Events

 Search events:
   


Bookmark and Share


Very Special Glee Episode

May 12 08:35

So, what did you think of last night’s Glee episode, featuring real-life quadriplegic Zack Weinstein?


Glee follows a high school glee club, and features a diverse cast of students ranging from Asian to gay to Jewish to wheelchair user. It’s a musical show, and at any time someone might just burst into song. The show often deals with social issues, which makes it sound tedious and boring, only with a soundtrack. But the show is edgy.


I think the show is some kind of satire, and I think the characters are actually caricatures of stereotypes. So, gay Kurt is over-the-top gay, uncomfortably so, and the discomfort comes from not knowing how to feel about him. Usually TV tries to program us to resist stereotypes, or laugh at them. But Kurt's ... ah ... complicated.


The show is gentler on Artie the Wheelchair Guy, probably because society’s not yet sure how to recognize disability stereotypes yet. And also, I’m sure the outcry at Glee casting a nondisabled guy to play Artie has caused the writers to go a little easy on this character.


I wonder, too, if the outcry over casting a walker as a wheelchair user is another reason why Zack made an appearance last night. His character was a football player who broke his neck, and his character was shown in two scenes. In both scenes, he was in bed with covers up to just below his arm pits (showing the injury level, maybe?), and we could see the back of his wheelchair.


Why, why, why was he shown in bed? Why couldn’t we have seen him up and about in society? Artie’s shown as having a full life as a high school student, why not this guy?


I can’t decide what the show’s motives are. First, this part of the show was dead serious – disappointingly so. Worse, it was uncritically inspirational! What a lost opportunity to exploit a stereotype. Second, this character acted like many high school kids who broke their neck last year might act. And Zack’s performance was flawless, in this respect. I bet he helped to write that dialog. But I don’t think most viewers know this. I think most viewers saw the episode and felt horrible that the poor broken football player no longer has a future. But maybe this was just his introduction, maybe we’ll get to see him develop into the fine young man most in his situation grow into. It will, however, be beyond strange to watch real-life AB Artie mentor the real-life quad, if the show goes that route. But then, that would sure fit how the show does things. It could be interesting.


Zack’s performance was great, and his singing voice isn’t bad. I hope he becomes a regular, that the show depicts him having a life, and takes off the kid gloves to give us the same strange, twisted treatment it gives all other typically stereotyped groups.

Post a comment about this blog!

Please enter a screen name.

Please enter a valid contact email.

Add your comments in the field below. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted. Please limit your comments to under 1,000 characters.
  chars
A value is required.





1. MarkPloch | May 21 11:03

I seriously doubt the show GLEE is going to influence any members of society either way. Nor should it have or expected to.

2. Josie | May 21 01:37

Mark, out of curiosity, what'd you think of this past week's episode, the whole dream sequence?

3. Shark7 | May 21 01:41

Mark, what planet do you live on? Here on planet earth, media controls the general public's thoughts and perceptions. So GLEE does control how the general public views wheelchair users.

4. Sallyfranz | Jun 03 03:06

I was actually ticked off in the episode of Artie dancing in the mall (it was as if his agent said, "you guys promised the kid a dance number") If you can't get out of a chair, make something good happen in the chair. Maybe there is hope with Zack that Glee can deal with issues of rage and humor. Sally Franz, Author Scrambled Leggs...A Snarky Tale of Hospital Hooey"/Amazon

5. www.deluxe4less.com | Feb 16 09:49

In the early 1900s, the firstwatches with http://www.deluxe4less.com matching pinwere made to wear on a lady'slapel. In 1915, the lapel [url=http://www.deluxe4less.com]fake watches[/url] was improved: The watch face was upside down so the replica watches wearer could read it more easily http://www.deluxe4less.com.

 

 

 





More Posts
  • 1 Percent
  • Gilenya Approved for MS - Yay!!
  • On Catching Fish
  • MS Cooling Tips
  • 20th Anniversary of ADA Reflection
  • Community Choice Act: Recession Proof
  • Very Special Glee Episode
  • Hope, Love, Trust and ADAPT
  • ADA: A Personal Reminiscence
  • ADA Celebration, New Mobility Style
  • I Choose to Be Me
  • ADAPT's Marsha Katz Weighs In
  • The Employment Advocacy Debate Continues
  • More Thoughts on Poverty, Employment
  • Debating Advocacy Priorities
  • Eggheady Thoughts on Employment
  • Relief for Haitians with Disabilities
  • Swine Flu, MS and Vaccines
  • Health Care Reform: Shhh ... Let it Cook
  • Thoughts on Compost
  • ADAPT's Marsha Katz Responds
  • ADAPT is Crazy
  • On Democracy
  • Hurricane Katrina: The Doctors' Choice
  • Power Wheelchairs and Health Care Reform
  • Yet Even More on Health Care
  • Health Care Update
  • Obama's ADA Speech Bombs
  • There is no Obama Health Care Plan
  • The Year of Community Living
  • Obama's Latest Disability Appointment
  • Obama Health Care Plan Details
  • Obama, Axelrod, Institutions ... uh oh
  • White House Questions and Conjecture
  • Stem Cells from Body Fat
  • Obama's Crip Problem
  • Paterson Spoof and Bloomie Blow-up
  • Navigating My Personal Energy Crisis
  • Understanding the Stim Package
  • Hey, Mr. President!
  • Dear Mark,
  • The Lewis Argument: Pity vs. Dignity
  • Time for a New Myth
  • Stop Humanitarian Award for Lewis
  • Let's Play ADA Mad Libs!
  • Accessible America Deadline is WEDNESDAY
  • Stocks Plummet as Tysabri Kills Again
  • Crime, Punishment and Quadriplegia
  • My Thanksgiving Gratitude List
  • WGAL Responds
  • Life, Death and Spinal Muscular Atrophy
  • Congratulations! Now get to work.
  • Goodbye, Sen. Rhoades
  • Political Thongs
  • ADA Amendments Act Silently Signed
  • Uber-Liberal Rep. Frank Arrests ADAPT
  • McCain/Palin Won't Budge on CCA
  • Some Lessons from 9/11
  • McCain and Palin, Bad News for Us
  • Michele Obama About her Dad, who had MS
  • Tropic Thunder is a Satire, Folks!
  • ADA Bill and Regs: What's the Diff?
  • McCain says No to Community Choice
  • Congratulate me on my new DORK VEST
  • Goodbye, Harriet
  • What Makes Crips so Tasty?
  • McCain has 40 ADAPT Activists Arrested
  • YES, I drank the Obama Kool-Ade!
  • Dear Hillary
  • Crip, Gimp and Other Naughty Words
  • Medical Lawsuits Gonna Get Harder
  • Barack Obama and Terri Schiavo
  • Justice! Florida Deputy Charged
  • Cop Dumps Quad from Wheelchair
  • We All Walk in Different Shoes
  • Fighting Back a Rogue Supreme Court
  • Funny Superbowl Ad in ASL
  • And Vying for the Disability Vote are...
  • New Ad Focuses on Candidate's Disability
  • The Candidates and Disability Issues
  • What Comes Next?
  • My Top 10 News Stories of 2007
  • Cartoon Characters with Disabilities
  • Personal Assistance and Turning 60
  • Stem Cells from Human Skin
  • Lights, Tints, and Equal Access
  • Deities and Disabilities
  • Goddesses, Freaks and Parasites
  • Strange but True Voting Tale
  • Damn You, Michael Gerson!
  • In Praise of Coffee
  • Flamethrowers, Family and Fatigue
  • Dying for Services
  • ADA Restoration: Help Pack the Room!
  • The Inevitable Nursing Home Bed
  • My Presidential Wish-List
  • Taking a Day Off on Account of Sun
  • Drug-related Injuries and Deaths
  • Oh, Sure, GLAAD Gets an Apology ...
  • The Quotable Jerry Lewis
  • Bring it on, U.S. Chamber of Commerce!
  • It's Time to Fix the ADA
  • Minneapolis' Marcelo Cruz and the Media
  • Voting: Talking with the Advocates
  • A Shout-Out to Rural Pennsylvania
  • An Accessible Voting Primer
  • Voting Machines: Access vs. Integrity?
  • I Have MS but I Don't Have CRABs!
  • More Thoughts on the Ashley Treatment
  • MiCASSA No Longer Exists
  • Red Machines, Blue Paper Trails
  • Baby-Free Stem Cells
  • Let the Crippled People Demonstrate
  • Ashley, Jack and CMS
  • Ask About the Sign
  • Don Imus, Slurs and Lame