Page 1 of 3 123>
Topic Options
#186782 - 05/12/10 06:28 AM If there is a Creation...
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
then there MUST be a Creator.
Top
#186785 - 05/12/10 10:27 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ævory]
ghoti
Member


Registered: 04/06/02
Posts: 8469
Loc: Ishpeming, MI 75.128.229.255
Is this meant to be a proof that God exists? If so, it falls short.

Things in nature are constantly being created and destroyed by perfectly natural means. Creation requires that there must be an application of force of some kind, but that doesn't necessarily prove that there is intelligence or design behind it.

Just because we don't currently fully understand the details about some of those forces doesn't prove that they have some divine origins.
_________________________
Feisty survivors populate this site. Avoid controversies unless you have a very thick skin.

Top
#186787 - 05/12/10 11:40 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
Paulwa_dup1
Member


Registered: 02/12/05
Posts: 4951
Loc: Washington
Just a thought, Ghoti but many scientists think of the universe a simlar to a giant engine with many parts and forces at work. If as they say the natural order of things n nature left to themselves is towards disorder and decay, how would you explain the building upward process in plain evidence. Yes we all may just be in a small window of time and circumstance that favors life and then things could change for our location drastically and wipe out life. We are learning many new and startling facts about our universe and beyond. To me we definately have a creator who is iin full control of His creation. There are many negative things that happen in our universe that we can't fathom but that may have real useful purpose to our creator. It is just life at work. Just my opinion as it has to be with anyone who thinks about these things.

If you take a creator out of the loop then where did matter come from? What forces could bring all these inanimate objects into a place to contain intelligence and life? Even giiven eternity with a decay and disorder pattern built in the way a clock winds down and not up?
Paul

Top
#186791 - 05/12/10 12:24 PM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: Paulwa_dup1]
ghoti
Member


Registered: 04/06/02
Posts: 8469
Loc: Ishpeming, MI 75.128.229.255
Paulwa, as you know I also believe in a creator. I just don't think it's within our mere human abilities to fully understand his/her/its nature and abilities.

Many chemicals can only come together in very narrow and precise ways to form compounds, so the process of creating new things is actually far less random than it may appear. The universe operates by the laws of nature, and IMO studying them is an excellent way to gain insight into the process of creation.

Whether that's by design or just the way the universe is put together is a matter of debate.
_________________________
Feisty survivors populate this site. Avoid controversies unless you have a very thick skin.

Top
#186794 - 05/12/10 01:20 PM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
Paulwa_dup1
Member


Registered: 02/12/05
Posts: 4951
Loc: Washington
What do you mean by the 'laws of nature' exactly, Ghoti? It seem to me this is just a catch all phrase we use when we don't have a clue as to how somethng works. Discussing this is a futile endeavor I think. I think faith in God's word is the order of the day to make any sense of things, but this doesn't work for many people. Don't think science is the tool that can explain these things and is a waste of time and brain power. The answer to all this is in a higher dimension or level where science as we know it cannot operate or give any answer. Science is a two dimensional tool attempting to analyze a multi dimensional space and environment.
Paul

Top
#186796 - 05/12/10 03:35 PM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: Paulwa_dup1]
flicka
Member


Registered: 04/06/00
Posts: 24616
Loc: SLO County, CA - 66.122.77.142
Here you go, Paul, consider this:
Quote:
In the very beginning, there was a void, a curious form of vacuum, a nothingness containing no space, no time, no matter, no light, no sound. Yet the laws of nature were in place and this curious vacuum held potential. A story logically begins at the beginning, but this story is about the universe and unfortunately there are no data for the very beginnings--none, zero. We don't know anything about the universe until it reaches the mature age of a billion of a trillionth of a second. That is, some very short time after creation in the big bang. When you read or hear anything about the birth of the universe, someone is making it up--we are in the realm of philosophy. Only God knows what happened at the very beginning. - Physicist Leon Lederman

Even Stephen Hawking agrees with him.
_________________________

"A lot of things were acceptable--until we stopped accepting it." -- Al Sharpton '12

Top
#186799 - 05/12/10 05:56 PM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: flicka]
Paulwa_dup1
Member


Registered: 02/12/05
Posts: 4951
Loc: Washington
That is probably as good a description that man could come up with, Flicka.
Paul

Top
#186809 - 05/13/10 06:37 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
Originally Posted By: ghoti
Is this meant to be a proof that God exists?


That would be silly, ghoti. I don't need proof to believe anymore than you need proof to disbelieve. I like how you qualified it as 'a' proof...as though there could be anything but THE absolute proof --- GOD being as BIG as He Is in this life of ours, it certainly would take a humdinger of a Proof...like, 'the' proof of His existence, huh?! So, no, this is not a proof that God exists. It's a belief.

Not only is it silly but also fruitless for both the believer and the nonbeliever ( absent the fun it is on a messageboard to debate over it & the fact that it makes ya think more about stuff...both stimulated by the believer's message as well as the nonbeliever's own). Let's suppose it Was absolute proof, then the nonbelievers would have to find something else to ghost-hunt over....

and.........as for the believer? well, it wouldn't matter if you came up with your own proof that He does not exist, does it? What....do you think that (any) proof, Even if it were the absolute proof of God's nonexistence, would settle anything?

I don't need proof that I believe in God any more than you need proof that you believe in Santa Claus. I mean, if you were to believe in Santa Claus, that is, at your age ....I wouldn't have any grounds to make you prove it to me. I'd just have to let you believe in him cus it made you happy. Why would I take that away from you. It might make you look crazy or stupid or childish to talk about it to others (you know, like that poor old actress who spoke out about her belief in past lives and reincarnation -- man, they blasted her allll over the tv news and such as being crazy....I always was disgusted in that because it was HER belief, damn it. If she wanted to talk about it then that was her business) You know who I'm talking about?,,that redhead...oh, shirley mclean, believer in new age stuff....I'm getting off the subject, sort of, but, really, why would I try to 'prove' you incorrect or...prove you to be talking nonsense? To make ME feel better?

Ghoti, maybe I'm pushing buttons so to speak just by posting what I did...knowing there are nonbelievers here. But, if they are all fired up about their 'nonbelief' status in life, why wouldn't they be posting about it? See....it's a BELIEVER who gets fired up! Gets fired up in a good way...............and it's the nonbeliever who then...has...something...to ghost-hunt about - but ony after they get the WORD. Take that away from him, and he'd have to find something else to dispell, and it wouldn't stop him from continuing on in the same fashion...so,...

I figure, ((( let's let Everyone be happy))): the believer keeps on believing bec there isn't anything to stop him. There isn't any proof that God does not exist. AND the nonbeliever gets to keep on poking around at the subject, cus, well...I've no idea why, really -- maybe cus it makes him happy--...seems pointless (at least a believe wants to spread around his happiness...it isn't like he's trying to make others miserable). Hey, is that what others think?!! <---- that Those who talk about God are trying to make a nonbeliever miserable? oh lord, the victimhood of it all! make it stop! make it STOP!

Hey, ghoti, you want to hear what my sis said when I mentioned the stupid hounding of paulwa here for being who he is....you know, the behavior that is readable still on the board? she said: oh God forbid there should be a bible thumper on the board. lol....I mean, really...so what?!

I have tried to wrap my head around just why things go the way they do on this board...you see what I just talked about is the exact same thing seen with the political forum. It isn't until someone of quite different political stance than the liberals here...(I know, I'm grouping liberals as the label cus it's just easier to describe what's happening/happened) posts something on the board that they believe that THEN you hear from the liberals..and, funny, but they're the same ones that try to dispell God's existence here on this forum...OR, else, if they are a believer, they certainly post accordingly with the others who try to debate a religious/biblical belief...so as not to offend Them (their nonbeliever friends). It is so weird, If one is all fired up about What they believe, whatEver that may be, ..political or otherwise, then, this being a messageboard for all, why does it take the 'opposition' to make this board breathe Any real life into it? Well....

...That/this is avory's expanation for everything..-----> That is the way God wants it! God wants there to Be Opposition -- It seems to make people happy...it isn't what He originally intended to Go with, cus, He wanted us to live in peace and harmony but, hey! He gave us free Will, and by observing us, he stumbled upon just what 'makes us tick' ... so, ..... Maybe if He had made us all the same instead of different, His plan would have panned out here on earth...HIS mistake, in that case (scenario) yet, He is perfect so He cannot make mistakes...hence, I prove avory to be correct in her explanation: God wants opposition so that everyone can be happy & those who say (as far as this board is concerned, now) that they are happy with the peace of the board, yada yada yada, ARE just....kidding themselves, and...kidding God, whether they are a believer or not.

So...why , I ask, again, does it take the believer...the republican...the opposition, to post around here before we get Life breathed into the board (political forum? other forums?)?

damn, I'm too good to be true! I better hustle up some proof that I exist because the opposition is gonna be "gunnin'" for me and the funny thing Is, they generally are the ones who don't like guns, too.

Here's a list to help keep things straight: no guns/and,or if you have them, don't shoot anything other than popbottles on a fence, no religion, and no republicans/conservatives (again, a generalization of the board so I can be lazy and not explain it allll) makes jack and jill a happy camper on new mobility - nøt. Add to the list if you like.

Top
#186810 - 05/13/10 08:03 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ævory]
ghoti
Member


Registered: 04/06/02
Posts: 8469
Loc: Ishpeming, MI 75.128.229.255
LOL - I own a bunch of guns, and use them for shooting at targets but also for hunting.

Ronda, if you've read any of my writings about religion around here you'd know that I absolutely DO believe that there is a creator. My view just happens to be a bit different than most other folks, but that's fine by me since I'm not out to look for converts or put down the faith of others.

I love to discuss religion and spirituality and do so often with my family and friends. It makes for interesting talks at times since I'm basically a Deist, my wife is Catholic, my son is agnostic, and my daughter is Wiccan. We all respect each others beliefs and can talk about them without anger or hostility.

I enjoy hearing others talk about their religious positions and have always tried to be respectful about it. The only thing I really find objectionable is when someone claims that their beliefs are the ONLY correct ones and that everyone else must follow their lead or be condemned.

IMO we must each find a way to commune with the creator and will do that in different ways. As long as your beliefs bring you serenity and comfort then all is well, but if your beliefs bring anger, hatred, and intolerance then you are likely on the wrong path.
_________________________
Feisty survivors populate this site. Avoid controversies unless you have a very thick skin.

Top
#186812 - 05/13/10 08:28 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
Originally Posted By: ghoti
LOL - I own a bunch of guns, and use them for shooting at targets but also for hunting.

Ronda, if you've read any of my writings about religion around here you'd know that I absolutely DO believe that there is a creator. My view just happens to be a bit different than most other folks, but that's fine by me since I'm not out to look for converts or put down the faith of others.

I love to discuss religion and spirituality and do so often with my family and friends. It makes for interesting talks at times since I'm basically a Deist, my wife is Catholic, my son is agnostic, and my daughter is Wiccan. We all respect each others beliefs and can talk about them without anger or hostility.

I enjoy hearing others talk about their religious positions and have always tried to be respectful about it. The only thing I really find objectionable is when someone claims that their beliefs are the ONLY correct ones and that everyone else must follow their lead or be condemned.

IMO we must each find a way to commune with the creator and will do that in different ways. As long as your beliefs bring you serenity and comfort then all is well, but if your beliefs bring anger, hatred, and intolerance then you are likely on the wrong path.


And yet, to no point do you make that you agree or disagree with my thoughts above you, here.

Also, I dearly love this paragraph..and what follows for that matter, it's been written by you a thousand times, so I Do know what you believe and don't believe. Back to the beloved paragraph:

Ronda, if you've read any of my writings about religion around here you'd know that I absolutely DO believe that there is a creator. My view just happens to be a bit different than most other folks, but that's fine by me since I'm not out to look for converts or put down the faith of others.

Essentially, LOL (rolling my eyeballs is truly what I'm more likely feeling than the laughing) what you say here is that you are ok with others' viewpoints because you yourself are not out to convert or belittle theirs....they, however are. And it is ok for you to point out others as being those who try to convert and belittle others' beliefs? This being because you recognize how different you are.......you being one not to do such morally, disgusting, ethically, crazy, loonie, bigoting, racist, pigheaded sort of thing. Your views are just a tad different? unless they are vastly different then I dont' see how you could have had such a bunch of debating with paulwa or chad or whatchamajiggie going on...I mean, ...?

Top
#186813 - 05/13/10 08:29 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ævory]
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
Originally Posted By: Paulwa_dup1
What do you mean by the 'laws of nature' exactly, Ghoti?
Paul

"The law of nature is that which God at the time of creation of the nature of man infused into his heart, for his preservation and direction. And this is lex oeterna, the moral law, call also the law of nature. And by this law, written with the finger of God in the heart of man, were the people of God a long time governed, before the law was written by Moses, who was the first reporter or writer of law in the world."

http://www.duhaime.org/legaldictionary/L/LawofNature.aspx

I am answering for you, paul, since ghoti went off to pee or something. LOL

Top
#186814 - 05/13/10 08:34 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
Originally Posted By: ghoti

As long as your beliefs bring you serenity and comfort then all is well, but if your beliefs bring anger, hatred, and intolerance then you are likely on the wrong path.


You mean, by others? anger by others? hatred by others? intolerance by others? Then what I (a for instance - it's me we are talking about) believe is likely to be the wrong path, you say?

Top
#186818 - 05/13/10 08:51 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ghoti]
ævory
Member


Registered: 04/04/05
Posts: 9657
Originally Posted By: ghoti
Is this meant to be a proof that God exists? If so, it falls short.

Things in nature are constantly being created and destroyed by perfectly natural means. Creation requires that there must be an application of force of some kind, but that doesn't necessarily prove that there is intelligence or design behind it.

Just because we don't currently fully understand the details about some of those forces doesn't prove that they have some divine origins.


In your own space and timeline of things, was nature here before God? And when did God come into your picture of space and time? prove that...?

Top
#186819 - 05/13/10 10:24 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ævory]
ghoti
Member


Registered: 04/06/02
Posts: 8469
Loc: Ishpeming, MI 75.128.229.255
Originally Posted By: ævory
Originally Posted By: Paulwa_dup1
What do you mean by the 'laws of nature' exactly, Ghoti?
Paul

"The law of nature is that which God at the time of creation of the nature of man infused into his heart, for his preservation and direction. And this is lex oeterna, the moral law, call also the law of nature. And by this law, written with the finger of God in the heart of man, were the people of God a long time governed, before the law was written by Moses, who was the first reporter or writer of law in the world."

http://www.duhaime.org/legaldictionary/L/LawofNature.aspx

I am answering for you, paul, since ghoti went off to pee or something. LOL


LOL, Ronda. I actually have a life outside of the internet, and once in a while it gets in the way of making instant replies.

By "laws of nature" I'm talking about things like gravity, the laws of thermodynamics, Newton's laws of motion, the laws that determine whether ionic or covalent bonds are possible between certain atoms and molecules, etc. The definition you provide refers to "natural law" and is from a website geared for lawyers. "Natural law" and "laws of nature" are two completely different things, ya know.
_________________________
Feisty survivors populate this site. Avoid controversies unless you have a very thick skin.

Top
#186823 - 05/13/10 10:56 AM Re: If there is a Creation... [Re: ævory]
flicka
Member


Registered: 04/06/00
Posts: 24616
Loc: SLO County, CA - 66.122.77.142
Originally Posted By: ævory

So...why , I ask, again, does it take the believer...the republican...the opposition, to post around here before we get Life breathed into the board (political forum? other forums?)?

When everyone agrees, there isn't much to talk about.
_________________________

"A lot of things were acceptable--until we stopped accepting it." -- Al Sharpton '12

Top
Page 1 of 3 123>


Hop to:

Generated in 0.257 seconds in which 0.231 seconds were spent on a total of 13 queries. Zlib compression disabled.